Confucianism

Tradition·Founded c. 500 BCE·uncounted — a tradition more than a membership

Confucianism

Branch
Precept of Confucianism

Filial piety.

Serve them living, bury them by the rites, sacrifice to them after — and do not damage the body they gave you, which is why Chinese men historically did not cut their hair. It outranks the state: asked about an upright son who reported his father for stealing a sheep, Confucius said that in his village uprightness meant the father covering for the son and the son for the father.

What it asksServe your parents while they live, bury them according to the rites, and sacrifice to them after. Do not damage the body they gave you
Who it bindsEveryone, and it outranks obligations to the state — Confucius says a son should conceal his father's theft
Where it bitesBy the requirement to remonstrate: filial piety includes telling a parent they are wrong, gently, repeatedly, and without resentment if ignored
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Xiao, filial piety, is the root virtue and the Classic of Filial Piety states its three stages: serving parents while they live, burying them according to the rites, and sacrificing to them thereafter. The prohibition on damaging the body received from one's parents is taken seriously enough to have shaped practice — it is a reason Chinese men historically did not cut their hair, and it complicated the acceptance of surgery, tattooing and cremation. The sharpest illustration of its priority over civic obligation is Analects 13.18, where the Duke of She boasts of an upright man in his district who reported his father for stealing a sheep, and Confucius replies that in his own district uprightness is different: the father conceals for the son and the son conceals for the father, and uprightness is found in that. Legal codes followed: imperial Chinese law generally exempted close relatives from the duty to inform, and the principle survives in modified form in contemporary Chinese and Taiwanese criminal procedure, which is a live comparative-law subject.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

The Duke of She said: in my district there is a man of upright conduct — his father stole a sheep, and he bore witness against him. Confucius said: in my district the upright are different. The father conceals for the son, and the son conceals for the father — and uprightness is found in this.

Analects 13.18 (rendered)

Kinship obligation over civic duty, stated without hedging; imperial law followed.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The dead are the first obligation. Haitian Vodou · core tenet Go deeper →
The samskaras — life, marked. Hinduism · rite Go deeper →
The alms round. Buddhism · rite Go deeper →
Asteya — and the merchant's word. Jainism Go deeper →
Repairing the world is human work. Judaism · core tenet Go deeper →
The dead are not out of reach. Christianity · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable