Confucianism

Tradition·Founded c. 500 BCE·uncounted — a tradition more than a membership

Confucianism

Branch
Story of Confucianism

Seven days looking at bamboo.

Taking Zhu Xi's instruction to investigate things literally, the young Wang Yangming and a friend sat in front of a stand of bamboo to find its principle. The friend collapsed after three days; Wang lasted seven and made himself ill. He concluded that principle is not out there in the bamboo, and built a philosophy on the failure.

Where it is toldWang Yangming's own account of his youth
Who appearsWang Yangming, a friend, a stand of bamboo
What it teachesThat taking Zhu Xi literally they sat and investigated bamboo to find its principle — the friend gave up after three days ill, Wang after seven — and that this failure is where his whole philosophy started
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Wang Yangming told the story about himself, which is what makes it useful. As a young man, taking seriously Zhu Xi's instruction that one extends knowledge by investigating things, he and a friend resolved to investigate the bamboo in his father's courtyard and find its principle. The friend concentrated on it for three days and fell ill; Wang persisted for seven and made himself ill as well, and they concluded they lacked the capacity to be sages. Years later, in exile at a remote post station in Guizhou, he reached the conclusion that the method had been wrong rather than the men: principle is not in the bamboo waiting to be extracted, it is in the mind, and the investigation of things means rectifying the mind's engagement with them. Everything in his philosophy — innate moral knowing, the unity of knowledge and action, the sufficiency of the mind — follows from that reinterpretation. It is the rare case where a philosophical school can be traced to a specific documented failure.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Awakening is uncovered, not acquired. Buddhism · core tenet Go deeper →
Let your yes be yes. Christianity · precept Go deeper →
Every child is born on the fitra. Islam · core tenet Go deeper →
Ritual without the heart is theatre. Sikhism · core tenet Go deeper →
Awakening is sudden, not gradual. Zen · core tenet Go deeper →
The koan breaks thought open. Rinzai · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable