Book of Kells, Chi Rho folio, c. 800 · public domain

Christianity

Tradition·Founded 30 CE·est. ~2.4 billion worldwide

Judaism → Christianity → 11 branches

Branch
Precept of Christianity

Turn the other cheek — and the argument about war.

The historic peace churches read the Sermon on the Mount as forbidding violence outright and have paid for that reading in every conscription since. The rest of the tradition uses just war doctrine, which permits force under conditions it then finds ways to satisfy. Both sides quote the same chapter.

What it asksDo not resist the evil-doer; turn the other cheek
Who it bindsTaken literally by the historic peace churches — Mennonites, Quakers, Church of the Brethren
Where it bitesAgainst just war doctrine, worked out by Augustine and Aquinas, which most of the tradition uses instead; the argument has never been settled
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The historic peace churches — Mennonites, Quakers, the Church of the Brethren — read the Sermon on the Mount as forbidding violence outright and have paid for it in every conscription of the modern era, with members jailed in both world wars and Mennonite communities repeatedly migrating to escape military service. The rest of the tradition uses just war doctrine, developed by Augustine and refined by Aquinas: right authority, just cause, right intention, proportionality, last resort, reasonable prospect of success. The honest criticism of it is that no state has ever failed to satisfy the criteria to its own satisfaction. The honest criticism of pacifism is that it is a position a minority can hold because a majority does not. Both sides quote the same chapter, and the argument has run for nineteen centuries without either winning.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.

Matthew 5:39 (KJV)

The peace churches and the just war tradition both build from this chapter.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Dirk Willems turns back across the ice. The Amish (Old Order) · story Read it in full →
Christians do not take up the sword — including for a just cause. The Mennonites · core tenet Go deeper →
Ahimsa — do no harm. Hinduism Go deeper →
Compassion extends to all sentient beings. Buddhism · core tenet Go deeper →
Non-violence is the highest duty. Jainism · core tenet Go deeper →
The Shoah broke something, and no answer has held. Judaism · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable