Confucianism

Tradition·Founded c. 500 BCE·uncounted — a tradition more than a membership

Confucianism

Branch
Precept of Confucianism

What was asked of women.

Follow the father, then the husband, then the son; cultivate conduct, speech, appearance and work. None of it is from Confucius, who barely mentions women at all. It was assembled in the Han and hardened over the next fifteen hundred years into footbinding, widow chastity arches and the exclusion of daughters from the genealogy.

What it asksThe three obediences and four virtues — a woman follows father, then husband, then son, and cultivates conduct, speech, appearance and work
Who it bindsNot Confucius, who says almost nothing about women. These come from the Han ritual texts and Ban Zhao, and hardened enormously afterwards
Where it bitesBy footbinding, by widow chastity arches, and by the fact that the tradition's own principle of remonstrance was never extended to the people it bound hardest
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The sancong side, three obediences and four virtues, comes from the Han ritual compilations and from Ban Zhao, not from Confucius, who mentions women almost not at all — the one notorious remark at Analects 17.25 about women and servants being difficult to keep is a single line whose interpretation is contested and which has borne a great deal of weight. The three obediences prescribe following the father before marriage, the husband after, and the son in widowhood; the four virtues cover conduct, speech, appearance and work. What matters is the trajectory: these hardened enormously in the Song and after, and the Neo-Confucian formulation attributed to Cheng Yi — that starving to death is a small matter but losing one's virtue is a grave one, offered in a discussion of widow remarriage — became a cudgel. The material consequences included footbinding, the state-sponsored erection of chastity arches honouring widows who refused remarriage or committed suicide, and the exclusion of daughters from lineage genealogies. The tradition's own principle of remonstrance was never extended to those it bound most tightly, and Chinese and Korean feminist scholarship has made this the central charge.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The dharma of one's station. Hinduism Go deeper →
The Five Precepts. Buddhism Go deeper →
Ahimsa at the table. Jainism Go deeper →
The commandments are how the covenant is lived. Judaism · core tenet Go deeper →
The Ten Commandments. Christianity Go deeper →
Halal — the lawful. Islam Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable