Shinto

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~100 million ritual participants, loosely held

Shinto → 1 branch

Branch
Precept of Shinto

Makoto — a sincere heart.

The nearest thing to a first principle, and it means the absence of a second, concealed intention rather than intensity of feeling. A rite done correctly with a divided heart is held to be worth less than one done clumsily with a whole one, and no one can check which you did.

What it asksMakoto — a sincere heart, meaning the absence of a hidden second intention
Who it bindsEveryone, and it is the nearest thing the tradition has to a first principle
Where it bitesBy the fact that it cannot be checked from outside. A rite performed correctly with a divided heart is held to be worth less, and nobody can tell
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Makoto — often written with the character for truth and read as sincerity — is the closest thing to an ethical first principle in a tradition that declines to write ethics down. It does not mean intensity of feeling; it means the absence of a second, hidden intention behind the first. Norinaga made much of it, arguing that the native Japanese way consisted in responding truly to things rather than in following imported Chinese moral systems, and setting it against what he considered the calculating quality of Confucian and Buddhist ethics. The practical consequence is that a rite performed exactly but with a divided heart is held to be worth less than one performed clumsily and wholly, which is a claim nobody can verify from outside, and that is precisely the point. It is also the concept that gets stretched thinnest: makoto has been invoked to praise self-sacrifice and single-mindedness in contexts, including the war, where the sincerity of the agent was not the morally relevant question.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The doorway, the tulsi, and the kitchen. Hinduism · rite Go deeper →
Awakening is uncovered, not acquired. Buddhism · core tenet Go deeper →
The kitchen. Jainism · rite Go deeper →
Shabbat — the palace in time. Judaism · the interior Go deeper →
Something in us is bent at the root. Christianity · core tenet Go deeper →
Wudu — the ablution. Islam · rite Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable