Shinto

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~100 million ritual participants, loosely held

Shinto → 1 branch

Branch
Precept of Shinto

Kegare, and staying away.

Death, blood, illness and childbirth are polluting — not wicked, polluting — and the polluted stay away from the shrine until it passes; the bereaved traditionally for around fifty days. The rules about menstruation and childbirth read now as plain discrimination, most shrines have quietly abandoned them, and a few mountains and festivals have not.

What it asksKeep kegare away from the kami — blood, death, illness and childbirth are all polluting, and pollution is a state rather than a fault
Who it bindsAnyone approaching a shrine; the bereaved traditionally stay away for around fifty days
Where it bitesOn menstruation and childbirth, where the old exclusions read now as straightforwardly discriminatory. Most shrines have quietly dropped them; a few festivals and sacred mountains have not
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Kegare is a state, contracted rather than committed, and the rules about it govern who may approach. Death is the strongest source — the bereaved traditionally abstain from shrine visits, kamidana offerings and festivals for around fifty days, and shrine gates are sometimes papered over during a household mourning. Blood is the other, which brought menstruation and childbirth under the same heading, and produced exclusions that are now the tradition's most obviously indefensible surviving feature. Most shrines have dropped them without announcement; the visible holdouts are specific festivals that bar women, and sacred mountains, of which Mount Ōmine in Nara remains formally closed to women and is periodically the subject of protest and of UNESCO discomfort. The Meiji government abolished many such prohibitions in 1872 and they persisted anyway. Defenders argue the categories were never about moral inferiority; the counter-argument is that a rule which in practice keeps women off the mountain does not become acceptable because its rationale is metaphysical.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The Manusmriti. Hinduism · scripture Open the book →
The kosher kitchen. Judaism · rite Go deeper →
Marriage, and what the churches ask of it. Christianity Go deeper →
Whether Sikhs should eat meat. Sikhism · core tenet Go deeper →
Do not defile the elements. Zoroastrianism Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable