Taoism

Tradition·Founded c. 500 BCE·est. ~12 million formally; far more informally

Taoism → 1 branch

Branch
Precept of Taoism

The account outlives you.

Chengfu, inherited burden: unresolved wrong is passed down, so present misfortune may be an ancestor's debt rather than your own fault. It is a theory of suffering that does not blame the sufferer, and it also makes the living permanently responsible for the dead, which is why so much of the practice is funerary.

What it asksUnderstand that the account does not close at your death
Who it bindsEveryone, whether or not they believe it
Where it bitesChengfu — inherited burden — holds that unresolved wrong is passed to descendants, and that you may be suffering for an ancestor. It explains misfortune without blaming the sufferer, and it also makes families responsible for the dead
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Chengfu, inherited burden, appears in the Taiping Jing and is one of the more distinctive Chinese explanations of misfortune. Karma in the Indian traditions individualises: what happens to you is what you did, in this life or another. Chengfu distributes across a lineage and across time: an ancestor's unresolved wrongs accumulate and press on descendants, so a person may be suffering for something done five generations back. The consequences are twofold and both matter. It removes the implication that the sufferer deserved it, which is pastorally significant, and it makes the living permanently responsible for the dead — the debts can be worked off, and much Taoist ritual, particularly the funerary and confessional rites, is explicitly about clearing them. It also explains why Chinese religious practice is so heavily oriented toward the ancestors: they are not merely remembered, they are an ongoing liability and an ongoing asset.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Karma is intention. Buddhism · core tenet Go deeper →
The soul is liberated by its own effort. Jainism · core tenet Go deeper →
Counting the Omer, and the fires of Lag BaOmer. Judaism · rite Go deeper →
The dead are not out of reach. Christianity · core tenet Go deeper →
Ziyarat — visiting the dead. Islam · rite Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable