Qur'an folio in gold Kufic, 9th c. · Cleveland Museum of Art · CC0

Islam

Tradition·Founded 610 CE·est. ~2 billion worldwide

Islam → 4 branches

Branch
Core tenet of Islam⚖ contested within

Leadership was appointed, not chosen.

Shia Islam holds that God designated Ali, and through him a line of Imams: the imamate is an article of faith, not a political arrangement. Sunni Islam holds that the community chose, and chose rightly. Nearly everything else that separates the two follows from this one disagreement.

Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Imamate is the actual dividing line, and describing Shia Islam as Sunni Islam plus mourning for Husayn gets it exactly backwards. For Twelvers the Imam is not merely a ruler but a divinely appointed, sinless guide who carries the authoritative interpretation of the Quran — which means Shia law, hadith, theology and prayer all rest on a different foundation, not merely a different opinion. Sunni Islam holds that prophecy ended and left the community, its scholars, and its consensus in charge, and that the caliphate was a practical office that could be well or badly filled. Zaydi Shia hold a lighter version: the Imam must be a qualified descendant who claims the office openly. Ibadi Muslims, mostly in Oman, reject the whole framework and elect their imam. The Amman Message of 2005 got scholars from all of these to sign a document recognizing each other as Muslims, which was not a small thing.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
P Peter — the rock that cracked. Christianity · figure Meet them →
The undivided church is the standard. The Old Catholic Church Go deeper →
One church, two thrones. The Armenian Apostolic Church Go deeper →
Jacobite is a word from outside. The Syriac Orthodox Church Go deeper →
Thomas came here in 52. The Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable