Qur'an folio in gold Kufic, 9th c. · Cleveland Museum of Art · CC0

Islam

Tradition·Founded 610 CE·est. ~2 billion worldwide

Islam → 4 branches

Branch
Story of Islam

Al-Hallaj.

He said ana al-Haqq — I am the Truth, one of the names of God — and was executed in Baghdad in 922 after years of trial. Sufis read the sentence as fana, the speaker gone and only God left speaking; the jurists read it as the plainest possible blasphemy. He is now quoted with reverence by people whose own schools would have signed the warrant.

Where it is toldThe Sufi biographies and the court records both
Who appearsMansur al-Hallaj, the jurists of Baghdad
What it teachesThat he said I am the Truth, was executed in 922 for it, and is now quoted as a saint by people whose own schools would have condemned him
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Mansur al-Hallaj was a Persian mystic who preached publicly in Baghdad, which was already unusual, and who is reported to have said ana al-Haqq — I am the Truth, al-Haqq being one of the names of God. After long imprisonment and a trial with political dimensions involving the Abbasid court, he was executed in 922, brutally and in public. The Sufi reading is that in the state of fana the speaker has been annihilated and it is not the man speaking; the juristic reading is that this is blasphemy however it is glossed, and a number of Sufis including Junayd distanced themselves at the time. He became the tradition's permanent test case for how far interior experience may be said aloud, and the standard Sufi conclusion was discretion rather than agreement — the sober path of Junayd was recommended precisely because Hallaj's was not survivable. He is now quoted with reverence in poetry from Persia to Punjab to Java, including by people whose own legal school would have upheld the sentence. Attar, Rumi and Iqbal all wrote about him.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The Black Pit. The Bahá'í Faith Read it in full →
Sound rightly spoken has power. Vedic Religion · core tenet Go deeper →
Samadhi — union in stillness. Hinduism · the interior Go deeper →
V Vairocana — the cosmic buddha. Buddhism · figure Meet them →
K Kundakunda. Jainism · figure Meet them →
God contracted to make room for the world. Judaism · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable