Leningrad Codex carpet page, 1010 CE · public domain

Judaism

Tradition·Founded c. 1000 BCE·est. ~15 million worldwide

Judaism → 8 branches

Branch
Precept of Judaism

Honour your father and your mother.

The fifth commandment, and the only one with a stated reward. The Talmud's example of perfect honour is a gentile — Dama ben Netina, who refused to wake his sleeping father to complete a large sale.

What it asksFeed them, clothe them, take them in and out — the Talmud measures honour in logistics, not in feeling
Who it bindsEvery Jew, including toward a parent who has not earned it
Where it bitesThe hard cases are the ones the codes actually discuss: a parent with dementia, a parent who is violent. Maimonides rules that a child may leave and appoint someone else to the care
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Kibbud av va-em is legislated as behaviour rather than sentiment, which is what makes it survivable. The Talmud defines honour as providing food and drink, clothing, and physically helping a parent in and out, and defines reverence as not sitting in their seat, not contradicting them in public and not calling them by name. It then works through the cases that actually arise: a parent who is losing their mind, a parent who throws money into the sea in front of their child, a parent who orders their child to break a commandment — which the child must refuse, because both are equally obligated. Maimonides rules that a child unable to bear a parent's dementia may leave and appoint others to provide the care, which is one of the more humane pieces of medieval law anywhere. The rabbinic exemplar of the commandment is deliberately a non-Jew: Dama ben Netina of Ashkelon, who lost an enormous sale rather than wake his father to fetch a key from under his pillow. The commandment carries no requirement to feel warmly, and the tradition's handling of abusive parents in contemporary responsa has moved, unevenly, toward permitting distance.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
C Confucius — the untiring teacher. Confucianism · figure Meet them →
Hanuman leaps the strait. Hinduism · story Read it in full →
The alms round. Buddhism · rite Go deeper →
Asteya — and the merchant's word. Jainism Go deeper →
The towel and the basin. Christianity · story Read it in full →
Adab — the courtesies. Islam Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable