The marja'iyya.
Every observant Twelver chooses a living scholar to emulate — a structure that keeps the tradition centralized in learning while the Imam remains hidden.
The marja'iyya is Shia Islam's answer to authority during the Imam's occultation: every observant Twelver selects a living grand ayatollah to emulate in matters of practice, and follows his rulings. It is a genuinely voluntary market for religious authority — believers may switch, and marja compete on scholarship and reputation — and it concentrates enormous influence, as Ali al-Sistani in Najaf demonstrates. It also generated the twentieth century's central Shia argument over whether clerics should govern directly, which Khomeini answered yes and Sistani, in practice, has not.
The same ground, other faiths
claims that share this one's ideasSign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.