Community consensus

Idea·held in 95 faiths·across 32 families·259 passages

All Ideas → The carriers → Community consensus

Say where you stand sign in — your answers stay private to you

What it means here

our wording, so the faiths below can be compared — never any tradition's own definition

Truth is discerned together; authority rests with the gathered community.

Every passage on this page is one faith's own phrasing. Sharing an idea is not agreement: Christianity and The Urantia Movement are both here because each says something this word covers, and what they say may flatly contradict each other. The idea is the place they can be set side by side.

Travels across32 of 52 families in the tree
Oldest holderZoroastrianism · c. 1200 BCE
Newest holderAnalog Sabbath · 2026 CE
Turns up as87 communitys · 50 tenets · 45 rites · 35 storys

Where it turns up

every faith that holds it, by founding date — time is half real and half rank order, because a straight axis crushes three millennia against the left wall. Hover a dot for the faith.
before record Hinduism · origins before record · 1 passageShinto · origins before record · 14 passagesYoruba Religion · origins before record · 7 passages Zoroastrianism · c. 1200 BCE · 10 passagesJudaism · c. 1000 BCE · 12 passagesJainism · c. 550 BCE · 6 passagesTaoism · c. 500 BCE · 8 passagesConfucianism · c. 500 BCE · 9 passagesBuddhism · c. 480 BCE · 5 passagesEpicureanism · c. 306 BCE · 1 passageStoicism · c. 301 BCE · 1 passagePyrrhonism (Scepticism) · c. 300 BCE · 1 passageChristianity · 30 CE · 16 passagesThe Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church · 330 CE · 1 passageThe Maronite Church · 410 CE · 1 passageThe Church of the East · 431 CE · 1 passageThe Assyrian Church of the East · 431 CE · 2 passagesThe Coptic Orthodox Church · 451 CE · 1 passageThe Syriac Orthodox Church · 451 CE · 2 passagesIslam · 610 CE · 12 passagesSunni Islam · 632 CE · 3 passagesShia Islam · 632 CE · 1 passageThe Druze Faith · 1017 CE · 1 passageEastern Orthodoxy · 1054 CE · 2 passagesThe Moravian Church (Unitas Fratrum) · 1457 CE · 2 passagesSikhism · 1499 CE · 8 passagesAnabaptism · 1525 CE · 1 passageThe Hutterites · 1528 CE · 1 passageAnglicanism · 1534 CE · 1 passageThe Mennonites · 1536 CE · 2 passagesThe Chaldean Catholic Church · 1552 CE · 2 passagesPresbyterianism · 1560 CE · 1 passageCongregationalism · 1582 CE · 2 passagesThe Eastern Catholic Churches · 1596 CE · 1 passageThe Syro-Malabar Church · 1599 CE · 2 passagesThe Baptists · 1609 CE · 1 passageQuakerism (Religious Society of Friends) · 1652 CE · 2 passagesThe Amish (Old Order) · 1693 CE · 2 passagesHaitian Vodou · 1700 CE · 11 passagesThe Church of the Brethren · 1708 CE · 2 passagesMethodism · 1738 CE · 2 passagesThe Armenian Catholic Church · 1742 CE · 1 passageThe Brethren in Christ · 1778 CE · 2 passagesThe Restoration Movement (Churches of Christ) · 1809 CE · 1 passageThe Plymouth Brethren · 1827 CE · 1 passageThe Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints · 1830 CE · 1 passageThe Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) · 1832 CE · 2 passagesThe Plymouth Brethren Christian Church (the Exclusive Brethren) · 1848 CE · 1 passageThe Religion of Humanity · 1849 CE · 1 passageThe Bahá'í Faith · 1863 CE · 14 passagesThe Old Catholic Church · 1870 CE · 2 passagesThe Ethical Culture Movement · 1876 CE · 3 passagesChristian Science (the Church of Christ, Scientist) · 1879 CE · 1 passageJehovah's Witnesses · 1879 CE · 1 passageAhmadiyya · 1889 CE · 1 passageThe Malankara Mar Thoma Syrian Church · 1889 CE · 2 passagesThe Church of the Nazarene · 1908 CE · 1 passageThe Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church · 1912 CE · 3 passagesThe Jacobite Syrian Christian Church · 1912 CE · 2 passagesThe Bruderhof · 1920 CE · 2 passagesReconstructionist Judaism · 1922 CE · 1 passageThe Christian Churches and Churches of Christ · 1927 CE · 2 passagesRastafari · 1930 CE · 1 passageThe Syro-Malankara Catholic Church · 1930 CE · 2 passagesSecular Humanism · 1933 CE · 2 passagesWicca · 1954 CE · 1 passagePeoples Temple · 1954 CE · 2 passagesAnanda Marga · 1955 CE · 1 passageThe Urantia Movement · 1955 CE · 1 passageChurch Universal and Triumphant · 1958 CE · 1 passageUnitarian Universalism · 1961 CE · 3 passagesDiscordianism · 1963 CE · 1 passageThe Ancient Church of the East · 1968 CE · 2 passagesThe Family International · 1968 CE · 1 passageThe Rajneesh Movement (Osho) · 1970 CE · 1 passageHeathenry (Ásatrú) · 1972 CE · 1 passageThe Twelve Tribes · 1972 CE · 3 passagesThe International Churches of Christ · 1979 CE · 3 passagesThe Church of the SubGenius · 1979 CE · 1 passageThe Eritrean Orthodox Tewahedo Church · 1998 CE · 2 passagesAleph · 2000 CE · 2 passagesJediism · 2001 CE · 2 passagesTerasem · 2004 CE · 1 passageThe Missionary Church of Kopimism · 2010 CE · 3 passagesEffective Altruism · 2011 CE · 2 passagesThe Satanic Temple · 2013 CE · 2 passagesThe Sunday Assembly · 2013 CE · 2 passagesAnalog Sabbath · 2026 CE · 1 passageOrdinary Time · 2026 CE · 1 passageSecond Copy · 2026 CE · 2 passagesThe Ledger of Small Kindnesses · 2026 CE · 2 passagesThe Long Now Assembly · 2026 CE · 1 passageThe Order of the Quiet Hour · 2026 CE · 1 passageThe Salt Line · 2026 CE · 1 passageThe Tuesday Reformed · 2026 CE · 1 passage ChristianityIslamAnglicanismJudaismAhmadiyyaTaoismAleph c. 1200 BCE2026 CE
Judaism 52 Islam 6 Vedic Religion 6 Sikhism 3 Aum Shinrikyo 1 Church of the Eternal Backup 1 Church Universal and Triumphant 1 Confucianism 1 Cynicism 1 Discordianism 1 Effective Altruism 1 Epicureanism 1

Another 20 families hold it with a single faith each — they are all in the sections below. 32 of 52 families in the tree carry it; the rest are silent on it, or we have not written them out far enough to know.

Across the faiths

one family at a time, and every family speaks before any family speaks twice — 95 of 171 faiths
Judaism — 52 faiths of this family hold it
Christianity 30 CE · God became human, died under empire, and did not stay dead. all 16 passages →
The church is the body of Christ. Not a metaphor of membership but of anatomy: many parts, one body, no part able to say to another I have no need of you. The community is the continued incarnation. Go deeper — context & 1 source →
Sunday. The first day of the week, kept because that is the day the tomb was found empty. Everything else in the practice hangs off it — the calendar, the working week of most of the planet, and the one hour a large minority of humanity still gives to something it cannot prove. When weekly — the first dayWho everyone; attendance is the measure of belonging Go deeper — context & 1 source →
also here 51 more faiths of this family hold it
Islam — 6 faiths of this family hold it
Islam 610 CE · There is no god but God — and life is submission to that fact. all 12 passages →
The law is for something. Jurists from al-Ghazali to al-Shatibi held that sharia exists to protect five things — religion, life, intellect, lineage, property — and that a ruling which serves none of them has lost its point. The maqasid argument is the main lever of modern reform, and literalists distrust it for exactly that reason. held by most Go deeper — context →
Jumu'ah — the Friday assembly. The week's one obligatory congregation: commerce pauses, the khutbah is preached, and shoulder meets shoulder in lines that ignore rank. When weekly — Friday middayWho the congregation — attendance is obligatory for men Go deeper — context →
Vedic Religion — 6 faiths of this family hold it
Hinduism A family of paths sharing dharma, karma, and liberation — not a single creed. Enter →
Satsang — the singing evening. Bhajans and kirtan with harmonium, dholak and cymbals, a reading, and food afterwards. No priest is required and no caste rule survives an hour of it intact, which is why bhakti movements have always run on it. When weekly — an evening in a front room or a hallWho Whoever comes; often the whole street Go deeper — context →
Sikhism — 3 faiths of this family hold it
Sikhism 1499 CE · One God beyond form; all people equal before it. all 8 passages →
Ardas — the standing prayer. Everyone rises, and the prayer runs through the ten Gurus, the martyrs, the shrines, then finally the specific request — a sick relative, a driving test, a new shop. It ends by asking for the good of all people, not only Sikhs, and any Sikh present may lead it. When daily — standing, at the close of every gathering large or smallWho the whole sangat, on its feet, hands joined Go deeper — context & 1 source →
Chamkaur — forty against an army. Besieged in a mud haveli, Guru Gobind Singh sent his two elder sons out to fight and watched both die. Then the five Sikhs left alive invoked the authority of the Khalsa and ordered him to escape — and he obeyed them, which is the point of the story. Read it in full — context →
Aum Shinrikyo — one faith of this family holds it
Aleph 2000 CE · What Aum became, still practising and still reporting to the state. Enter →
Aleph says the crimes were the acts of individuals. The state says the group is the same group. Aleph's public material treats 1994 and 1995 as the work of members who have since been tried and executed, and points to the compensation it pays. The Public Security Intelligence Agency treats Aleph as the same organisation under a different name, with the same object of devotion. A reader is entitled to both statements and to the fact that they conflict. ⚖ contested within Go deeper — context →
The renaming, and the split. Joyu Fumihiro renamed the group Aleph in February 2000 and tried to build a version of it that did not centre on Asahara. By 2007 the majority had gone back to Asahara-centred practice and Joyu left with a few hundred people to found Hikari no Wa. Aleph is what stayed. Read it in full — context →
Church of the Eternal Backup — one faith of this family holds it
Second Copy founded on Panfaith · The copy is not you. Keep it anyway. Enter →
Say the disclaimer out loud. Before every sync a member states plainly that this will not save them. The practice survives the honesty; the comfort does not. Go deeper — 1 source →
The disclaimer. Spoken before the backup runs: "This will not save me. I am doing it for you." Then the sync. When weekly — Sunday, before the syncWho each member, aloud Go deeper →
Church Universal and Triumphant — one faith of this family holds it
Church Universal and Triumphant 1958 CE · Speak the decree out loud, fast, and the light answers. Enter →
March 1990, in the shelters. Members had built and stocked fallout shelters at the Montana ranch on Prophet's reading of a coming nuclear attack. The date passed. The church acknowledged the failure and stopped naming dates. Read it in full — context →
Confucianism — one faith of this family holds it
Confucianism c. 500 BCE · Society as ritual: become fully human through the forms. all 9 passages →
The Mandate of Heaven can be taken away. Heaven authorises a dynasty to rule and withdraws the authorisation when it misgoverns — and the evidence of withdrawal is that people rebel and succeed. It is simultaneously a doctrine of legitimacy and a licence for revolution, and every Chinese dynasty has had to live with both halves. Go deeper — context →
Charye, and the journey. A daytime rite at New Year and at the autumn festival for several generations at once, followed by grave-clearing. The rite takes twenty minutes. Getting there produces the largest annual movements of human beings on the planet, and that is the part that costs something. When annual — Lunar New Year and the autumn harvest festivalWho the whole extended family, in the eldest son's house Go deeper — context →
Cynicism — one faith of this family holds it
Stoicism c. 301 BCE · Two handles on everything; take the one you can hold. Enter →
Stoic Week. A free seven-day course run each October since 2012 by Modern Stoicism, with a public conference, Stoicon, alongside it — online in recent years, and scheduled for 17 October in 2026. When Annual, each OctoberWho Anyone with an internet connection; free Go deeper — context →
Discordianism — one faith of this family holds it
Discordianism 1963 CE · A joke disguised as a religion, disguised as a joke. Enter →
The Principia Discordia. Typed, hand-lettered, rubber-stamped and pasted together, then photocopied. It carries no copyright — the notice reads ALL RITES REVERSED, REPRINT WHAT YOU LIKE — which is why it survived without a publisher and why no edition is authoritative. Language EnglishComposed 1963-1970, in five editions Open the book — context & 1 source →
Effective Altruism — one faith of this family holds it
Effective Altruism 2011 CE · Work out where the money does the most good, then send it there for the rest of your life. Enter →
Whether the far future outweighs everything happening now. The longtermist argument is that the number of people who could exist dwarfs the number who do, so reducing existential risk beats treating malaria. It split the movement and the split has never closed. ⚖ contested within Go deeper — context →
November 2022. FTX collapsed, and with it the largest funder the movement had ever had. What followed inside effective altruism was a year of public self-examination that its own writers described in the language of a crisis of faith. Read it in full — context →
Epicureanism — one faith of this family holds it
Epicureanism c. 306 BCE · Nothing to fear in the gods, nothing to feel in death. Enter →
E Epicurus — the man who left money for a dinner. His will freed slaves, provided for the children of a dead colleague, and paid for the school to keep eating together once a month. It is a strikingly institutional document for a philosophy about withdrawing from institutions. Domain Pleasure correctly understood as the absence of painStanding Wrote some three hundred rolls; three letters and forty doctrines survive intact Meet them — context →
Haitian Vodou — one faith of this family holds it
Haitian Vodou 1700 CE · Serve the lwa well, and the lwa serve life. all 11 passages →
Vodou is not the word. In Haiti the word names a particular dance and rhythm; the religion is what you do, and people say they serve the lwa. Voodoo in English is an American invention of the occupation years and means something Haitians do not recognise, which is why the spelling of the word is itself a political position. ⚖ contested within Go deeper — context →
The indemnity. In 1825 France sent warships and demanded 150 million francs in compensation for the loss of its colony and its slaves as the price of recognition. Haiti borrowed from French banks to pay it and finished settling the debt in 1947. Every account of Haitian poverty that omits this is incomplete, and Haitians never omit it. ⚖ contested within Read it in full — context & 1 source →
Heathenry (Ásatrú) — one faith of this family holds it
Heathenry (Ásatrú) 1972 CE · The old gods of the North, honored again. Enter →
Keep your oaths. Words spoken over the horn are binding; the old ethic is less commandment than reputation — courage, honesty, hospitality, and a word that holds. Go deeper — context →
Jediism — one faith of this family holds it
Jediism 2001 CE · A prank on four censuses that some of the respondents meant. Enter →
Whether this is a religion at all is answered differently in two countries. The Temple of the Jedi Order holds United States tax-exempt status as a church. On 16 December 2016 the Charity Commission for England and Wales refused the same body charitable registration, finding that Jediism lacks the necessary spiritual or non-secular element and could be followed as a secular belief system. Jedi themselves split the same way. ⚖ contested within Go deeper — context & 1 source →
The census of 2001. A chain email claimed, wrongly, that a religion recorded by enough people would win official recognition. In England and Wales 390,127 wrote Jedi, making it the fourth largest answer to the religion question; New Zealand recorded the highest share anywhere. No agency counted it as a religion. The figure fell to 176,632 in 2011, and for 2021 the Office for National Statistics filed Jedi Knight under No religion. Read it in full — context →
Pilgrims of the Last Tuesday — one faith of this family holds it
The Tuesday Reformed founded on Panfaith · Grief does not keep a calendar. Enter →
You tell one person that you did it. The parent line practises alone. The Reformed require a single witness, named in advance, told afterwards. Go deeper →
Pyrrhonism (Scepticism) — one faith of this family holds it
Pyrrhonism (Scepticism) c. 300 BCE · Suspend judgement, and the quiet arrives on its own. Enter →
Ordinary life, held loosely. Sextus lists four things that guide conduct without requiring any belief: nature, feeling, custom and training. A sceptic goes to the temple, votes, practises medicine, and asserts nothing. When Ongoing, and in whatever the local calendar saysWho Anyone; the sceptic does what the neighbours do Go deeper — context →
Shinto — one faith of this family holds it
Shinto The kami are everywhere — Japan's way of the spirits. all 14 passages →
Shinto and Buddhism were one system for a thousand years. Shinbutsu-shūgō: kami were understood as local manifestations of buddhas, temples and shrines shared compounds, and priests served both. The state forcibly separated them in 1868, destroying a great deal in the process. Most Japanese people still use both and see no problem. ⚖ contested within Go deeper — context →
Hatsumōde. The first shrine visit of the year, made by roughly three-quarters of the country in the first three days of January. Meiji Jingū alone handles around three million people. Most of them will tell a survey they have no religion, and they will queue in the cold for an hour anyway. When annual — the first three days of the yearWho more or less everyone in Japan Go deeper — context →
Taoism — one faith of this family holds it
also here Taoism
The Church of the SubGenius — one faith of this family holds it
The Deep Water People — one faith of this family holds it
also here The Salt Line
The Ethical Culture Movement — one faith of this family holds it
The Missionary Church of Kopimism — one faith of this family holds it
The Rajneesh Movement (Osho) — one faith of this family holds it
The Religion of Humanity — one faith of this family holds it
The Satanic Temple — one faith of this family holds it
also here The Satanic Temple
The Sunday Assembly — one faith of this family holds it
The Urantia Movement — one faith of this family holds it
Transhumanism — one faith of this family holds it
also here Terasem
Wicca — one faith of this family holds it
also here Wicca
Yoruba Religion — one faith of this family holds it
also here Yoruba Religion
Zoroastrianism — one faith of this family holds it
also here Zoroastrianism

Where it is argued

passages a tradition marks as contested inside itself — the disagreement is theirs, not ours
The altar call. Charles Finney formalised it in the 1830s with the anxious bench, and it is now how a large share of the world's Christians date their conversion. Critics inside evangelicalism argue it manufactures decisions; it has survived every one of those critiques for two centuries. When weekly — at the close of the serviceWho anyone who comes forward Go deeper — context →
The midweek study. Eight people, a front room, one passage, and the assumption that ordinary readers can handle the text. It is the engine of Protestant practice and the reason literacy campaigns and missions travelled together — and the reason lay readings sometimes outrun what the clergy would prefer. When weekly — midweek, in someone's front roomWho six to a dozen people, led by a layperson Go deeper — context →
Who pays. The plate, mostly. Germany is the exception worth knowing: a church tax of eight to nine percent of income tax, collected by the state and handed over, which gives the German churches enormous budgets and gives Germans a bureaucratic way to leave — a few hundred thousand file the form each year. Go deeper — context →
The splits. 451 over how to say Christ is one person; 1054 between Rome and Constantinople; 1517 across the West. The 1054 excommunications were mutually lifted in 1965 and the churches still do not share communion, which shows how little the formal gesture settles. Go deeper — context →

Travels with

where community consensus appears, these tend to appear beside it — counted off the passages they share All ideas →
Built on Hatchable