The sages — Hillel, Akiva, and the argument that made the religion.
Akiva began learning at forty and was flayed by Rome with the Shema in his mouth. He also endorsed Bar Kochba as messiah, which ended in catastrophe, and the tradition keeps both facts on the same page.
The sages are the reason Judaism survived the destruction of its cult, and the tradition treats them as colleagues rather than saints. They are quoted by name, argued with, corrected, and occasionally shown behaving badly — the Talmud records rabbis losing their tempers, misjudging, and being overruled by their own students. Hillel and Shammai's schools disagree for generations until a heavenly voice announces that both are the words of the living God and the law follows Hillel, on the stated grounds that his students were gracious and taught the opposing view first. Akiva's biography carries the tradition's ambivalence in one life: an illiterate shepherd who began at forty, built the interpretive method the whole system runs on, backed a failed messiah in a revolt that cost hundreds of thousands of lives, and died under Roman torture reciting the Shema. Nobody prays to any of them. Their graves are visited, especially in the Galilee, especially by Sephardi and Hasidic Jews, and the more rationalist end of the tradition is uneasy about that.
The same ground, other faiths
claims that share this one's ideasSign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.
