Borobudur at sunrise · Justine Hong · CC BY 2.0

Buddhism

Tradition·Founded c. 480 BCE·est. ~500 million worldwide

Vedic Religion → Buddhism → 3 branches

Branch
Core tenet of Buddhismheld by most

The teaching bends to the hearer.

Upaya, skillful means: what gets said depends on who is listening and what will actually free them. It is why the canon contradicts itself, and why the tradition does not read that as a defect.

Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Skillful means is the tradition's explanation for its own inconsistency, and it is offered without embarrassment. A teaching is a tool aimed at a particular listener's particular knot; a different listener gets a different tool, and the tools may contradict. The Lotus Sutra gives it the famous illustration — a father promises his children three kinds of cart to get them out of a burning house, and gives them all one better cart, and is not judged a liar. Critics inside and outside the tradition point out how easily this licenses saying anything, and the counter-check offered is functional: the test of a teaching is whether it reduces suffering, not whether it is doctrinally tidy.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Truth has many sides. Jainism Go deeper →
Guard the tongue. Judaism · precept Go deeper →
Love of God and neighbor is the whole law. Christianity Go deeper →
Bhai Kanhaiya's water. Sikhism · story Read it in full →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable