Borobudur at sunrise · Justine Hong · CC BY 2.0

Buddhism

Tradition·Founded c. 480 BCE·est. ~500 million worldwide

Vedic Religion → Buddhism → 3 branches

Branch
Precept of Buddhism

The meat argument.

The Buddha ate meat and refused to ban it; East Asian Mahayana banned it anyway. Two and a half thousand years later this is still the most-argued ethical question in Buddhism.

What it asksDo not kill, and do not have an animal killed for you
Who it bindsContested by school and country — mandatory in East Asia, not in Theravada or Tibet
Where it bitesThe threefold rule permits meat not seen, heard, or suspected to be killed for you; industrial supply chains make that test almost unusable
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The Buddha ate meat, permitted monastics to eat it, and explicitly refused Devadatta's demand to make vegetarianism compulsory — the rule he set instead was the threefold one: a monastic may not eat flesh they have seen, heard, or reasonably suspect was killed for them. The logic is about complicity in the intention, not about the meat. Mahayana sutras later rejected this outright, and East Asian monasticism has been strictly vegetarian for over a millennium; Tibetan and much Theravada practice is not, for reasons that are partly agricultural — very little grows at four thousand metres. The modern argument is that the threefold rule was written for a world where you could tell, and a supermarket is not that world.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

Monks, I allow fish and meat that are pure in three respects: not seen, not heard, not suspected to have been killed on your account.

Jivaka Sutta (rendered)

The rule as given — about complicity, not diet.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Ahimsa — do no harm. Hinduism Go deeper →
The panjrapole. Jainism · community Go deeper →
The suffering of living things. Judaism Go deeper →
The ox and the bell. Confucianism · story Read it in full →
Take it easy, and do not preach about it. Dudeism (The Church of the Latter-Day Dude) Go deeper →
Love of God and neighbor is the whole law. Christianity · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable