Meenakshi Temple gopuram, Madurai · Vyacheslav Argenberg · CC BY 4.0
ॐ

Hinduism

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~1.2 billion worldwide

Vedic Religion → Hinduism → 8 branches

Branch
Story of Hinduism

Ekalavya's thumb.

A tribal boy refused instruction learns archery in front of a clay image of the teacher who turned him away, and outshoots the prince. Drona asks for his right thumb as the teacher's fee, and receives it.

Where it is toldThe Mahabharata, Adi Parva
Who appearsEkalavya, Drona, Arjuna
What it teachesWhat the epic itself recorded about the price of a teacher's promise
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Ekalavya is a Nishada, a forest tribe, refused instruction by Drona because Drona has committed to teaching royal students. He builds a clay figure of the teacher, practises before it, and becomes better than Arjuna, at which point Drona — who has promised Arjuna he will be the finest archer alive — asks for gurudakshina, the teacher's fee, and names the right thumb. Ekalavya cuts it off. The tradition has read this in at least three ways: as a demonstration of ideal devotion to a teacher, as an indictment of Drona's pettiness which the epic makes deliberately, and, in twentieth-century Ambedkarite reading, as a straightforward record of how talent from outside the permitted castes was disposed of. That third reading has become dominant in Indian public discourse; Ekalavya's name is attached to schools for tribal children and to Dalit student organisations. A version in which Ekalavya later regains his skill and fights on the other side exists in the epic, which does not soften the scene.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
Sky-clad and white-clad. Jainism · community Go deeper →
The priests, and the miko. Shinto · community Go deeper →
Babalawo, and the argument about iyanifa. Yoruba Religion · community Go deeper →
The Coonan Cross Oath. The Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church Read it in full →
A Alexander Mack — first baptised, and refused as founder. The Church of the Brethren · figure Meet them →
B Barton Stone — the revivalist who would not keep a title. The Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) · figure Meet them →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable