Meenakshi Temple gopuram, Madurai · Vyacheslav Argenberg · CC BY 4.0
ॐ

Hinduism

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~1.2 billion worldwide

Vedic Religion → Hinduism → 8 branches

Branch
Story of Hinduism

Shambuka.

A brahmin's son dies, and the sages tell Rama the cause is a shudra performing austerities, which this age does not permit. Rama finds Shambuka and beheads him, and the boy revives.

Where it is toldThe Ramayana, Uttara Kanda
Who appearsRama, Shambuka, and a brahmin whose son had died
What it teachesThe passage the tradition argues hardest about having kept
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The Shambuka episode appears in the Uttara Kanda, the last book of the Ramayana, which many scholars and many Hindus regard as a later addition — the same book contains Sita's banishment. In it, a brahmin brings his dead son to Rama's court and blames the death on adharma somewhere in the kingdom; the sage Narada identifies the cause as a shudra performing tapas, which the treta yuga does not permit. Rama searches, finds Shambuka hanging upside down over a fire, confirms his caste, and kills him, at which the child revives and the gods approve. It is the single most cited passage in the anti-caste critique of Hinduism. Defenders argue interpolation, or read it allegorically, or note that other recensions handle it differently. It has also been rewritten repeatedly from inside the tradition: Bhavabhuti dramatised it in the eighth century with visible discomfort, and twentieth-century Tamil, Marathi and Malayalam writers have staged it as a straightforward indictment, some of them prosecuted for doing so.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The nuns' lineage question. Buddhism · community Go deeper →
To save a life, break the law. Judaism · precept Go deeper →
What was written down about women. Sikhism · precept Go deeper →
The Heavenly Commandments, as state law. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom · precept Go deeper →
Ahimsa at the table. Jainism · precept Go deeper →
The good Samaritan. Christianity Read it in full →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable