The Interior of Islam

Tawakkul.

Reliance on God, and the tradition spends most of its energy on the distinction from fatalism. The hadith is blunt about it: a man asks whether he should let his camel loose and trust God, and is told to tie the camel and then trust God. The work comes first; the reliance is about what you do with the part you cannot control.

Add to My Beliefs →

Reached throughAfter you have tied the camel — the hadith is explicit that you do the work first

What it is likeThe specific relief of having done what you can and stopped carrying the rest

What it signifiesTawakkul, reliance. The tradition spends most of its energy distinguishing it from fatalism, because the two are easy to confuse from outside and from inside

Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Tawakkul is reliance on God, and the tradition spends most of its energy distinguishing it from passivity, because the two are easy to confuse. The definitive text is a short hadith: a man asks whether he should leave his camel untied and trust God, and is told to tie it and then trust God. Umar is reported to have rebuked people who sat in the mosque calling themselves reliant, saying the one who relies is the one who puts seed in the ground. The theological content is a division of labour — you are responsible for the means, God for the outcome — and the psychological content is the specific relief of having done what you can and being able to stop carrying the rest. Al-Ghazali devotes a book of the Ihya to it and works through the failure modes carefully, including the person who neglects obvious precautions and calls it faith, and the person who takes every precaution and calls the result their own achievement.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

Tie your camel, and then trust in God.
Hadith, Sunan al-Tirmidhi (rendered)
The line the tradition uses to separate reliance from fatalism. The work comes first.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas

Job. Christianity · story Read it in full →

Grace does the work; your effort is mostly getting out of the way. Hinduism · core tenet Go deeper →

No one made this, and no one is running it. Buddhism · core tenet Go deeper →

The Tirthankaras cannot help you. Jainism · core tenet Go deeper →

The binding of Isaac. Judaism · story Read it in full →

The ninth Guru's stand. Sikhism · story Read it in full →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Where next

← Fana.the previous passage in Islam Standing at Arafat. →the next passage in Islam Islam's Practice roomback up one layer Propose a change to this passageone button — it routes to the review pool