Leningrad Codex carpet page, 1010 CE · public domain

Judaism

Tradition·Founded c. 1000 BCE·est. ~15 million worldwide

Judaism → 8 branches

Branch
Community of Judaism

The woman who cannot leave.

Israel's rabbinical courts have jailed men for years for refusing to grant a divorce. American courts cannot touch it, so activists have used public shaming and, in one case that ended in federal convictions, kidnapping and beatings.

How you joinNot a group anybody joins — a status a woman is trapped in
Who leadsA rabbinic court, which can pressure a husband and in Israel jail him, and cannot issue the document in his place
The unitThe agunah — chained. A Jewish divorce is a writ the husband must give of his own free will, and some will not
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

A Jewish marriage is created by the husband's act and can only be dissolved by his act: he must place a get, a writ of divorce, in his wife's hands of his own free will. If he refuses — out of spite, for leverage in a custody negotiation, or for money — she is an agunah, chained, unable to remarry under Jewish law, and any children of a subsequent relationship are mamzerim with severe marital disabilities of their own. A man in the same position is treated far more leniently. Israel's rabbinical courts have real coercive powers and have imprisoned refusers for years; outside Israel the courts have no jurisdiction, so the community has used social pressure and public shaming, and in one notorious case a rabbi ran a service using kidnapping and cattle prods, ending in federal convictions in 2015. The mainstream remedy is prevention: the Beth Din of America's halakhic prenuptial agreement, now close to universal in Modern Orthodoxy, imposes a large daily support obligation on a husband who separates without giving a get. Much of the Haredi world rejects it. Structural solutions — conditional marriage, or annulment by a rabbinic court — have been proposed for a century and repeatedly refused, and this is the case that liberal movements point to as the clearest cost of an unchanging law.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

He writes for her a document of severance and places it in her hand.

Deuteronomy 24:1 (rendered)

Eleven centuries of legal ingenuity have failed to get around the word he.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The nuns' lineage question. Buddhism Go deeper →
What was written down about women. Sikhism · precept Go deeper →
The Heavenly Commandments, as state law. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom · precept Go deeper →
Ahimsa at the table. Jainism · precept Go deeper →
The good Samaritan. Christianity · story Read it in full →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable