Leningrad Codex carpet page, 1010 CE · public domain

Judaism

Tradition·Founded c. 1000 BCE·est. ~15 million worldwide

Judaism → 8 branches

Branch
Community of Judaism

Ordaining women, and where the line is drawn.

The practical arguments are about function rather than learning: whether a woman may lead a service requiring a minyan she is not counted in, and whether the partition can move. Sephardi and Mizrahi communities have largely stayed out of the argument, which is itself a data point about whose argument it is.

How you joinSeminary, examinations, and a title. The title is where the fight is
Who leadsReform ordained Sally Priesand in 1972, the Reconstructionists Sandy Eisenberg Sasso in 1974, the Conservative movement Amy Eilberg in 1985. Orthodoxy has not
The unitYeshivat Maharat in the Bronx has ordained around a hundred Orthodox women since 2009, mostly as maharat or rabbanit; the Rabbinical Council of America ruled in 2015 that it will not accept women rabbis under any title
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The non-Orthodox movements settled this decades ago: Reform ordained Sally Priesand in 1972, the Reconstructionists Sandy Eisenberg Sasso in 1974, and the Conservative movement Amy Eilberg in 1985 after a long and bitter fight that produced a breakaway seminary. Orthodoxy has not, and the argument there is about function rather than capacity — nobody now claims women cannot learn the material, since women's advanced Talmud study is established in Modern Orthodox institutions in New York and Jerusalem, and yoatzot halacha, women who advise on the laws of niddah, are widely accepted. The contested questions are whether a woman may hold a communal office, lead parts of a service requiring a quorum she is not counted in, and carry the title. Yeshivat Maharat, founded by Sara Hurwitz and Avi Weiss in 2009, has ordained around a hundred women, most using maharat or rabbanit rather than rabbi; the Rabbinical Council of America resolved in 2015 that it will not ordain or recognise women rabbis under any title, and the Agudath Israel position is harder still. Partnership minyanim, which divide the service so women lead the parts that do not require a quorum, operate in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, New York and London and are not recognised as Orthodox by the Israeli rabbinate. The related fight over the mechitza — how high, how opaque, and whether the women's section can be beside rather than behind — is the same argument conducted in plywood.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The masjid. Islam Go deeper →
Caste has no standing here. Sikhism · precept Go deeper →
Assemblies, not clergy. The Bahá'í Faith Go deeper →
No creed — a covenant. Unitarian Universalism · core tenet Go deeper →
A presbytery writes its own will and dies. The Restoration Movement (Churches of Christ) · story Read it in full →
Everything in one purse. The Twelve Tribes · core tenet Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable