Harmandir Sahib, Amritsar · Bernard Gagnon · CC BY-SA 4.0

Sikhism

Tradition·Founded 1499 CE·est. ~26 million worldwide

Sikhism → 1 branch

Branch
Story of Sikhism

Water thrown the wrong way.

At Hardwar the pilgrims were throwing Ganges water east to the sun for their dead ancestors. Nanak began throwing it west; when they objected, he said he was watering his fields in Punjab, which was at least a shorter distance.

Where it is toldThe janamsakhis — Nanak at Hardwar
Who appearsNanak, and pilgrims throwing water at the sun
What it teachesIf your water can reach the ancestors, mine can reach my fields
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

The Hardwar story is Nanak's method in miniature: not argument, but a demonstration that makes the argument unnecessary. Pilgrims at the Ganges were throwing water eastward toward the rising sun as an offering to dead ancestors; Nanak waded in and began throwing water west. Asked what he was doing, he said he was watering his fields back in Punjab, and when told water cannot travel that far, asked how theirs was reaching the next world. The story is used against shraadh rites specifically, and the Rehat Maryada duly forbids Sikhs from performing them. It is also the model for how Sikh preaching handles ritual it considers empty — by making the person perform the absurdity themselves rather than by condemning them, which is a rhetorical style Punjabi audiences still expect from a good katha.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The samskaras — life, marked. Hinduism · rite Go deeper →
Obon — feeding the hungry ghosts. Buddhism · rite Go deeper →
T The Stove God. Taoism · figure Meet them →
Ancestor veneration. Confucianism · rite Go deeper →
Muktad — the dead come home. Zoroastrianism · rite Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable