Christian Science (the Church of Christ, Scientist)

Movement·Founded 1879 CE·The church does not publish membership figures and is forbidden to by its own Manual, Article VIII, Section 28. Independent estimates for the late twentieth century range from under 100,000 to several hundred thousand and are not reconcilable. What can be counted is public: practitioners and teachers listed in the Christian Science Journal in the United States fell from 4,965 in January 1971 to fewer than a thousand, and branch churches from roughly 1,800 to about 1,000.

Judaism → Christianity → Catholicism → Protestantism → Christian Science (the Church of Christ, Scientist)

Branch
Core tenet of Christian Science (the Church of Christ, Scientist)

This is a science, and it is meant to be demonstrated.

The claim is not that God may grant a cure if petitioned but that the method Jesus used is repeatable, teachable and available now. That word — demonstration — is why the church publishes testimonies with verification requirements and why the failure of a case is read as a failure of understanding rather than of the system.

Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Eddy chose the word Science deliberately and defended it against every objection: the claim is that the principle is fixed, the method is teachable, and the results are reproducible, in the way that a mathematical rule is. The church's publishing arm has run verified testimonies of healing since the 1880s, and the current requirement is that a published testimony be corroborated by three people who can vouch for the account or knew of the healing. Independent researchers have not been able to evaluate these as clinical evidence, since diagnosis is usually absent by design. The consequence inside the movement is theologically severe and is acknowledged: when a case does not heal, the failure is located in the understanding of the practitioner or the patient rather than in the system, which puts the weight of a death onto the people who were praying.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The Orit, and the books in Ge'ez. Judaism · scripture Open the book →
The Ginza Rabba. Mandaeism · scripture Open the book →
The Rigveda. Vedic Religion · scripture Open the book →
The Vedas & Upanishads. Hinduism · scripture Open the book →
The Pali Canon. Buddhism · scripture Open the book →
The Agamas. Jainism · scripture Open the book →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable