Shinto

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~100 million ritual participants, loosely held

Shinto → 1 branch

Branch
The Interior of Shinto

Doing it without believing it.

Around three-quarters of Japanese people report no religion, and a similar share visit a shrine at New Year. From outside this looks like hypocrisy or cultural residue. From inside it is not a contradiction: the tradition asks for correct practice and never asked for assent, so there is nothing to be insincere about.

Reached throughBy going to the shrine at New Year, buying the charm, and telling any survey that you have no religion
What it is likeNot like belief. Like doing the correct thing
What it signifiesAround three in four Japanese people report no religious affiliation and a similar share visit a shrine at New Year. Shinto's own position is that orthopraxy is the whole of it, which makes the apparent contradiction not one
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Japanese survey data look paradoxical from outside: roughly seventy percent report no religious belief or affiliation, while a similar proportion visit a shrine or temple at New Year, buy charms, hold a jichinsai before building, and have a Buddhist funeral. Reported figures for people affiliated with Shinto and Buddhism, when institutions self-report, together exceed the population of Japan. The resolution is that the Japanese word shūkyō, religion, is a Meiji-era translation coined largely with Christianity in view, and carries connotations of doctrinal commitment, exclusive membership and organised proselytising — which most Japanese people genuinely do not have, and which the Aum Shinrikyo attacks in 1995 made actively distasteful. Shinto never asked for assent to propositions; it asked for correct practice. So a person who visits the shrine, keeps the rites, and says they have no religion is not being inconsistent by the tradition's own standards, only by a definition of religion the tradition did not write. Whether this is a profound point about orthopraxy or a comfortable way of describing habit is exactly the argument, and Japanese scholars of religion conduct it vigorously.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The unit is the temple. Buddhism · community Go deeper →
Rosh Chodesh — the new moon. Judaism · rite Go deeper →
Sunday. Christianity · rite Go deeper →
The jiao. Taoism · rite Go deeper →
The Jashan. Zoroastrianism · rite Go deeper →
The Nineteen-Day Feast. The Bahá'í Faith · rite Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable