Meenakshi Temple gopuram, Madurai · Vyacheslav Argenberg · CC BY 4.0
ॐ

Hinduism

Tradition·Founding date unrecorded·est. ~1.2 billion worldwide

Vedic Religion → Hinduism → 8 branches

Branch
Core tenet of Hinduism⚖ contested within

The world is an appearance you have mistaken for a fact.

Maya, in Shankara's Advaita: Brahman alone is real, the world is neither exactly real nor exactly unreal, and ignorance is the only thing that ever needed removing. Ramanuja and Madhva both rejected it outright — for them the world is God's and therefore real.

Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Maya is the most famous Hindu idea in the West and the most consistently misdescribed. Shankara is not saying the world is a hallucination — he is saying it has a lower grade of reality, the way a dream is real while you are in it, and that Brahman alone is real without qualification. The rope-and-snake analogy is his: you did not see nothing, you saw something and misidentified it. Ramanuja's attack is that this makes the scriptures, the teacher, and Shankara himself unreal, which is self-defeating; Madhva's is blunter still. What almost nobody in the tradition holds is the popular version in which the world does not matter — Advaita renunciates run hospitals and schools, and Shankara himself is said to have spent his short life walking the length of India arguing. The scope here is contested for a reason: presenting Advaita as Hinduism's position is the single most common error in English writing about it, and it is largely Vivekananda's doing.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

From the unreal lead me to the real; from darkness lead me to light; from death lead me to deathlessness.

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1.3.28 (rendered)

Chanted at the opening of countless events in India by people who would not call it a prayer.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The soul is light in exile. Mandaeism Go deeper →
Matter, sickness and death are errors of belief, not facts about the world. Christian Science (the Church of Christ, Scientist) Go deeper →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable