Qur'an folio in gold Kufic, 9th c. · Cleveland Museum of Art · CC0

Islam

Tradition·Founded 610 CE·est. ~2 billion worldwide

Islam → 4 branches

Branch
H Figure of Islam

Husayn — killed at Karbala.

The Prophet's grandson refused allegiance to Yazid, rode out with about seventy companions, and was surrounded and killed on the plain of Karbala on 10 Muharram 61 AH — October 680. Shia Islam is organized around that death the way Christianity is organized around a crucifixion.

Names & titlesal-Husayn ibn Ali — Sayyid al-Shuhada, lord of the martyrs
DomainRefusal, and the price of it
RelationsSon of Ali and Fatima; grandson of the Prophet
Depicted asA riderless horse, a slashed water-skin, an empty cradle — the imagery stays oblique on purpose
StandingThird Imam to Twelvers; honored by Sunnis, but not mourned by them every year
Understanding it — context, not catechism: how this passage is held

Karbala is the single event that most shapes how a fifth of Muslims feel about power. Husayn was invited to Kufa, abandoned by the Kufans, cut off from the Euphrates for three days, and killed with his male household on the tenth of Muharram; the women and the surviving son were taken captive to Damascus. Shia liturgy retells this every year in enormous detail and with deliberate emotional force, and the annual mourning is not commemoration so much as re-entry. The political reading — a small band refusing an unjust ruler — has been used by Iranian revolutionaries, Lebanese parties, Indian anti-colonialists and Gandhi alike, and by their opponents. Sunnis honour Husayn without mourning him annually, fast on Ashura for a different reason, and generally find the self-flagellation practised by some Shia distasteful; a number of senior Shia jurists agree and have discouraged bloodletting in favour of blood donation.

From the sources — the passages this rests on; concise renderings, cited

Far, far from us is humiliation.

Attributed to al-Husayn at Karbala, in the maqtal literature (rendered)

Hayhat minna al-dhilla — painted on banners across Iraq and Iran every Muharram.

The same ground, other faiths

claims that share this one's ideas
The Zafarnama — the letter of victory. Sikhism · scripture Open the book →
O Ogou. Haitian Vodou Meet them →
T The demons, who are not simple. Hinduism Meet them →
The pegs in his ears. Jainism · story Read it in full →
The Shoah broke something, and no answer has held. Judaism · core tenet Go deeper →
S Satan — the adversary. Christianity Meet them →

The conversation

argument stays attached to the claim it is about All discussion →

Sign in to open the first thread. Everything here is attributed.

Built on Hatchable